The money for the benchmark category has run out; even upgrading to level three only gets you 120,000.

In Shantou's ninth-batch inclusion notice, there is a sentence that combines the funding for two types of projects into one.

On November 16, the Shantou Municipal Bureau of Industry and Information Technology issued the notice for the ninth batch of applications for inclusion in the database, with four paragraphs in the main text. The first item of the fourth paragraph contains only one sentence, but that sentence is valuable.

Original text: “Given that the number of projects in the digital transformation benchmark category included in the project pool has reached the quota, projects applying this time for awards and subsidies in the digital transformation benchmark category and projects applying for awards and subsidies in other digital transformation categories will, if they pass the project pool entry review, all be awarded and subsidized according to the support standards for projects in other digital transformation categories.”

Put it in terms businesses can understand: the quota for benchmark-type projects has been used up; if you apply as a benchmark now, even if approved, you will be funded as an ordinary project.

500,000 and 120,000 were originally two separate plates

This Shantou application guide (revised edition) divides projects into two categories, with very clear standards.

Digital transformation benchmark project: a subsidy of no more than 50% of the approved project investment costs (excluding tax), with an upper limit of RMB 500,000 per enterprise project. The digitalization level must reach Level 3 or above after the transformation is completed.

Other digital transformation projects: likewise no more than 50%, with an upper limit of RMB 120,000 per enterprise project. Must reach Level 2 or above.

The two figures differ by 380,000. Moreover, during the policy's validity period, the same small and medium-sized enterprise undertaking digital transformation can receive at most one award/subsidy and may apply for only one project.

So when enterprises make plans, they do the math: since they can only apply once, they aim for the benchmark. To qualify for Level 3, they add MES, implement equipment connectivity, and supplement data collection, increasing the investment from 300,000 to 600,000. Calculated at 50%, they would have been able to get 300,000 originally; the benchmark cap of 500,000 does not block it, and 300,000 is received.

Now that this notice has come out, with the same investment of 600,000, under the standards for other categories, 50% is 300,000, but the cap is reduced to 120,000. That's a difference of 180,000.

Not a single cent of the extra 300,000 invested was recovered.

Another difference between the two types of projects lies in the thresholds. The benchmark category requires reaching Level 3 or above after the upgrade, while other categories only require Level 2 or above. Used in reverse, this threshold is a sieve: if your system only reaches Level 2, you are not qualified to go for the benchmark in the first place, and forcing a submission will only get it returned.

By the way, regarding the basis for the base amount. Shantou, like Foshan, calculates the approved project investment expenses only from software, cloud services, and necessary equipment expenditures, excluding implementation fees, customization fees, training fees, and maintenance fees; the amount is determined as the minimum of the three documents: the contract, the tax-exclusive invoice amount, and the payment voucher.

This is actually a good thing for small projects—the base is small, so it is not easy to hit the 120,000 cap. But for projects that have invested 600,000, 120,000 is a hard cap; no matter how clean the base is, it is useless.

So the reality of this Shantou program is: the vast majority of enterprises ultimately receive the 120,000 tier, and keeping investment at around 240,000 is the most cost-effective. If you want to get more on a single project, you have to wait for other funds at the provincial or national level; don't fixate stubbornly on this one.

When it comes to the credit limit, the document doesn't tell you when it will run out

There's a catch here, I need to make it clear.

The notice only said “the quota has been reached”; it did not say what the quota was, did not say how many items had been warehoused in the first eight batches, and did not say whether more would be added later. Enterprises had no way to judge in advance. All you can see is this notice and the result it gives.

This is not unique to Shantou. Urban pilot funds are allocated in block grants; each city's project pool has a total cap, and once it is full, projects can only be funded at the ordinary tier—similar wording has appeared in documents from Guangzhou, Foshan, and Dongguan, though not stated this bluntly.

What is more troublesome is the order of determination. The original text says, 'Projects applying for benchmark-category subsidies and projects applying for other-category subsidies, if they pass the database entry review, will all be assessed according to the other-category standards.' In other words, the money is determined at the review stage, not when you fill out the application. Selecting 'benchmark' in the system does not mean you can get the benchmark money.

So should we still push for level three?

Yes. The results of the tiered assessment will not only serve this one subsidy—they will also be used later in evaluations for technical transformation, specialized, refined, distinctive and innovative enterprises, and smart factories. But if your project calculation sheet back-calculates investment based on the “benchmark 500,000,” this sheet now needs to be recalculated—working backward from the 120,000 cap, investment tops out at around 240,000; anything beyond that is out of your own pocket.

Another easily overlooked restriction: during the policy validity period, if the same enterprise implements one or more digital transformation projects during the policy period, regardless of whether they are carried out by the same lead unit, it may select only one of the projects to apply for awards and subsidies.

Enterprises with multiple factory sites and phased system implementation need to select candidates in advance. Which one to choose? Not the one with the largest investment, but the one with the most complete investment documentation and the highest evaluation rating. In the system, list the candidate projects by project number, check off the four types of documents—contract, invoice, payment, and acceptance—one by one, and exclude first those missing any one of them.

As for which company's products to use, the document also leaves an opening. Enterprises may choose products from the 'Shantou City Provincial-Level Small and Medium-Sized Enterprise Digital Transformation City Pilot Digital Product List', or recommend products themselves; however, for self-recommended products, at the time of application they must also submit explanations of product functions, application scenarios, service cases, and price reasonableness, as well as proof of having been included in other cities' pilot product lists, itemized quotations for product modules, service contracts for similar products in the past three years, intellectual property proof, agency authorization, functional and security testing reports, and other such materials.

This requirement is a threshold for our industry: a quote must be breakable down to modules. A vague “system construction fee of 380,000” won't pass the price reasonableness review; it must be broken down into how much for finance, purchasing/sales/inventory, production, and reporting respectively, what problem each module solves, and what similar customers have done. If you don't keep records according to this standard in normal times, you won't be able to put the materials together at short notice.

January 8 is not the company's deadline

The date in this notice that is easiest to misread is January 8, 2027.

The original text states: All district and county industry and information technology departments are requested to submit the application materials for projects that meet the application conditions to the Municipal Bureau of Industry and Information Technology by January 8, 2027.

This is the deadline for districts and counties to report to the city, not the deadline for enterprises to report to districts and counties. Enterprises must submit to the district/county, and the district/county must conduct a preliminary review, compile, and hand over; moving it forward by two weeks is a conservative estimate. Preparing according to the end of December is relatively safe.

Another noteworthy sentence in the notice reads: “Continue to do a good job in the routine application work for digital transformation projects, and adhere to the practice of reporting one (or a batch) once it (or they) matures.”

This means it is not a one-time window; it is rolling acceptance. Report early and you are ranked early; report late and you are ranked behind. For a pool with limited total funding, ranking is money.

The materials list is also in the guidelines, seven items, two of which are directly relevant to our industry: proof of the digitalization level rating after transformation, and photos of the enterprise site and digital equipment, as well as screenshots of the digital system running.

Many people stumble on the item of system operation screenshots. The screenshots they provide are of the login page, homepage dashboard, or a beautifully designed BI big screen—but what the reviewers want to see is whether the system is actually running the business. Sales order lists, production work orders, inventory transactions, and purchase receipt records—the kind with dates and document numbers—are the valid evidence.

One more point that is easy to miss: supporting enterprises upstream and downstream of the pilot industries can also apply, but they must provide supporting documents such as supply contracts. The category under which a supporting enterprise applies must be the same as that of the pilot industry enterprise it supports.

Three things you can do this week

1. First, confirm whether you can reach Level 3. If you can't reach Level 3, you don't qualify for the benchmark category anyway—just prepare according to the other categories. Don't write it as a benchmark in your materials; that would be a waste of effort.

2. Recalculate the project investment table based on the upper limit of 120,000. For those that have already exceeded it, remove the excess portion from the application basis to avoid being questioned during review that the investment does not match the award and subsidy.

3. Submit the materials to the district/county before the end of December; don't wait until January 8. Retake a batch of system operation screenshots, with document numbers, dates, and operators.

关于我们

​我们致力于帮助中小企业实现数字化转型,我们的团队由一群充满激情和创新思维的专业人士组成,他们具备丰富的行业经验和技术专长。

扫一扫获取顾问以及手册

Sign in to leave a comment
For the same Odoo contract, Guangzhou includes the implementation fee, while Foshan and Shantou do not.
Guangzhou’s third batch closes on November 22; let’s put the award and subsidy base calculation methods of the three places side by side.